Bernadette was allowed to leave at that point; she told the FBI agent she wanted time to think. Bernadette was nice, and I considered her a friend in class. Bernadette saw her carefully cultivated outward persona crumbling with every passing mile as the two cars returned to Orinda city limits. according to the Associated Press in1984. according to a 1985 Los Angeles Times article. Please reload CAPTCHA. People get more time for getting caught with marijuana. So, she confessed to her parents who called the police., Palmer attended the trail. Elaine, who was studying the Bible, set her kitchen timer and resumed reading. The film became a TV movie phenomenon, according to entertainment news site Monsters and Critics. I would rather die," according to CNN. Only God decides where Bernadette will spend eternity. I think it is safe to say that anyone can see, that the motivation would be, that Kristen would tell people what Bernadette did. Kirsten would of outgrown it long before now if she would of lived if she was a Bully or just a plain Snob. If Bernadette is truly unforgivable, then thats a judgement for either the courts or God. [3] I suppose her bristly exterior some described her as not nice was likely a way to protect herself socially, since she likely didnt have a ton of self confidence (in math, anyways). Yes, she couldve punched her or just avoid Kirsten the next day at school but Bernadette didnt want to be embarrassed and thats why she did it. People have feelings to. Rene heard banging on the door but she was home alone and thought Kirsten was at a Bobbys meeting. Orinda is totally corrupt, from top to bottom. Miamonte, were interested in tge Bernadette Protti case. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Palmer recalls that Costas and Protti were in Moraga when Costas got out of the car. Bernadette was smart but had no idea that Kirsten wouldnt be interested. P.S. And the bullying and harassment from fellow students at Miramonte continues to this day. Sure Bernadette had fit the description, right down to the Pinto. She called Raymond and all three met at the police station where Bernadettes confession was recorded. She cant come to her Hometown without someone seeing her and remembering her, or go around chikdhood friends anymore, so how could Kirsten of made it worse than it is for her today? I was dumbfounded that she got 9 years. Her jealousy was the opener to the murder and all she had to do was throw that anger into that 18 inch knife and there you have ita dead 15 year old Northern California girl. But she had fallen out with them and, by the time Kirsten was murdered, Nancys animosity towards Kirsten was well known. I feel tremendous sympathy for her brother who lost his only sibling. Protti had volunteered to drive her. Kirsten had commented on the shabbiness of her equipment, and Bernadette rankled at what she saw as Kirsten passing judgement on her. Her father Raymond was a retired public works officer, who taught Christianity in his spare time. It wasnt long into the trip that Kirsten realised that the dinner shed been told about was not an actual thing. Protti, in 1984. Peter et Kirsten Costas ont tous deux eu Orinda, en Californie, comme maison d'enfance. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Now that she had her foot in the door, surely all she had to do now was simply put her hand out. Were you people even there? I thought after 30 years you people who were her age would have matured already. Bernadette Protti was sentenced to a maximum of 9-years, but was released 7-years later on parole. It was definitely a tragedy. Required fields are marked *, Student Sep 4, 2022 at 12:51 am. In the end she will answer to GOD regardless. Why did Bernadette have that knife in her car? She had it coming. I dont feel like shes been adequately punished., Protti was charged with second-degree murder. While the police reviewed the case using the profile, Berit and Arthur Costas hired a private investigator. The police had assumed that the killer would have crumbled within minutes of interrogation, which suggested that none of them ever parented a teenage girl. Her father Raymond was a retired public works officer, who taught Christianity in his spare time. I hope time heals all wounds. Both were members of the swim team, but Costas was reportedly much more popular than Protti, according to the Associated Press in 1984. She wouldnt of been so popular. Who is killing the cheerleader cast? There are laws for both. Background: The daughter of affluent parents, Arthur and Berit Costas, Kirsten and her brother, Peter, grew up in the small suburban town of Orinda, California. Bibi Lee Feb 8, 2016 at 11:21 pm. Corporate drudge escapee writing recipes, tips & discount alerts.. But would I go kill a person for taking all the stuff i wanted even if I ever tried hard? And besides that, shed passed a polygraph. The ridiculous punishment for thr most heinous crime. Or again are fabricating, lying, and passing judgment more then ever. Bernadette refused to plead to premeditation and the trial to prove whether a 16-year-old teen knew she was going to murder her fellow Bobbie went ahead in March 1985. She collapsed on the ground as the door opened. Sharon Palmers daughter was a lot like Kirsten a funny person and Confident, and likeable. Orinda Native May 22, 2019 at 10:53 pm. Her exact words were: My friend is acting weird and Im really scared. Time limit is exhausted. He began by reviewing the existing evidence, including the interview notes and lie detector tests. Polygraphs are foolproof, as history will attest. Coupled with the witness account from Alexander Arnold of the killer with the blonde hair and casual attire driving the Pinto, a scenario was beginning to form in the minds of investigators. She was self absorbed and full of Confidence. Bernadette faced a sentence of 9 years for second-degree murder charges. The only people who defended her actions about belittling people were people who were in her social, mean club! Kirsten was on the cheerleading camp that Bernadette herself was supposed to be enjoying at that moment. And now everyone was going to find out how weird she really was. In that moment, becoming a social outcast in a place like Miramonte High School was a fate worse than death. Bernadette served her time and was released. . Coverage of the latest true crime stories and famous cases explained, as well as the best TV shows, movies and podcasts in the genre. How can you Justify a girl who Savagely murdered and let the blame rest on 2 Innocent. With no break in the case by October 1984, authorities were relieved when an FBI profile theyd requested arrived. One small good thing came out of it, and thats that the grades that were affected started treating each other a bit better, realizing that words can hurt. As Kirsten fell, the knife was driven twice into her back. Your brain might not be fully developed until age 25, but sadly I dont believe that a shitty personality at 15 will suddenly become a kind personality at 25. Nancy didnt help her situation entirely: she had initially lied to investigators that she was at a movie at the time of the murder instead of with her boyfriend. While in custody Bernadette graduated from high school, earned a bachelors degree in nursing and has been writing nursing text books. The next day, every single female student made sure to attend school, regardless of whether they were ill or not. They are theories that people who have some screws missing post!! I hope that damn school has learned a lesson. I remember that night so vividly. It seems somewhat appropriate for the sentence to be handed down on April Fools Day: given that Bernadette had tried to plead guilty to the lesser charge, this meant the Contra Costa County had forked out tens of thousands of dollars to find out an answer they already knew. She writes her articles on her crazy life, including one piece on her grandmother, who is Student Perspectives: Keeping Schools Safe From Gun Violence, BSU Honors Black Culture Through Campus Activities, Welcome to 2023: Student New Years Resolutions, Its Written in the Stars: Your November Horoscope, Your email address will not be published. Bernadette Peters. Get good grades and make your parents proud so they could go flaunt you off to other parents. The defence wasnt disputing that Bernadette had killed Kirsten; they were only arguing that it wasnt her intention to do so when she had set up the meeting. It seems that Kirsten misconstrued Bernadettes desperation for her friendship as something sexual by referring to Bernadette as that way, so it is unsurprising that Mrs Palmer and others in Orinda came to the same conclusion. So she had more money than they deployed, and she wasnt the Outcast they made her out to be, wasnt as popular as Kirsten, but she was Close. Critically injured, Kirsten was transported to hospital. When girls like Costas torment/bully girls like Bernadette, the tormented can just flip.
Kirsten Costas, a 15-year-old teen living in the small suburban California town of Orinda, was stabbed to death by her classmate Bernadette Protti, then also 15, on June 23, 1984. Bernadette was sure that once Kristen was her friend, success would follow. Bernadette Peters. Martin has returned for the new Lifetime remake, this time as an FBI agent investigating the murder, according to the Daily Herald, a Chicago-based outlet. She jumped out of the car and ran to the home of Alexander Arnold. viewed 15 April 2017, Wikipedia.com Murder of Kirsten Costas Consumed by guilt, she writes a letter to her parents before leaving the family home and surrendering herself to the police. The comment above should be ignored. Well, guess what? Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! He told me his mom heard the shrieks from Kirsten as she staggered across the street tot he Hill residence, where she collapsed and died upon opening of the front door. Hear about the real crime that Alexey's favorite Lifetime movie is based off, as well as a tasting from a delightful coffee birthday gift! He described seeing a chunky teenaged girl with stringy blonde hair in track pants driving a Ford Pinto. I have often wondered what has happened to Bernadette, did she ever have children and if she did had she told them what she had done? Did you know Kirsten.? Bernadette did not give her name during this call, only saying that it was to be a secret known only to the Bobbies. LOL How stupid it is to even suggest that! No excuse for Bernadette she was a Beast. I am surprised this hasnt happened more than once. Kirsten came running up to the car, clearly expecting to see someone from her usual inner circle. Kirsten Costas reminds stabs to death classmate Bernadette Protti. It was a crime of passion!!!! Bernadette Protti was a very sweet girl who wanted nothing more than to be Kirstens friend. (function( timeout ) {
CAMPOLINDO HIGH SCHOOL 300 MORAGA ROAD MORAGA CA, Kate Ginley, Staff WriterOctober 14, 2014. Palmer also recalled the presentation of the physical evidence. Get real, according to reports by FBI who found out the truth Bernadette wanted to befriend Kirstin who in turn did not like her aggressive behavior. Get all your true crime news from Oxygen. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Bernadette Protti had been charged with first-degree murder in the June 23 slaying of 15-year-old Kirsten Costas. 72.10.35.84 That night, Bernadette told her mother they needed to talk, but Elaine Protti said she was tired. But the hours passed, and nothing. Besides her crime, there isn't much about her online. mr. a. It also wasnt outside the realm of possibility that Kirsten refused to go to a party to which she hadnt been invited, and Bernadette responded to this by throwing a temper tantrum like a three-year-old in desperation. Poor Bernadette, after all her hard work she still isnt popular enough for her own Wikipedia page. So she had a few she didnt like, who doesnt. Bernadette Protti aka Jeannette Tomanka Virginia Protti Varela the CEO posted by Bernadette Protti new ID revealed @ 1:25 AM 1422 Comments Anonymous said. The FBIs profile was read out to her and she was asked whether the profile reminded her of anyone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g61Ud0qeE, Bernadette Protti documentary Kirsten Costas, a 15-year-old teen living in the small suburban California town of Orinda, was stabbed to death by her classmate Bernadette Protti, then also 15, on June 23, 1984. What a horrible person. Formerly known as Bernadette Protti. In addition, Kristen was a high school student from the United States who was murdered in June 1984 by Bernadette Protti, a classmate. Once the rumour took off, Nancy was a virtual pariah, bullied every day for her role in Kirstens death. But she was just 15 and had her whole life in front of her. Soon after this, Bernadette put her hand up for the Year Book team, but again she was not accepted. Protti was tried as a juvenile. It sounds like the premise of a Lifetime movie (and, well, it is!) I wish Bernadette all the best. They have endured the most anger and pain then anyone. Bernadette sat in the Pinto, unsure what to do next. In the end, the wannabe cheerleader was found guilty of second degree murder, with the judge rejecting the idea that the murder was premeditated. Whatever the truth, Kirsten screamed at her that she was being weird. The daughter of affluent parents, Arthur and Berit Costas, Kirsten and her brother, Peter, grew up in the small suburban town of Orinda, California. The police finished all interviews, ran down all leads, and came up empty. In response, Bernadette started stabbing.
If all teen girls were to be Murdered over being a. Anonymous Dec 13, 2019 at 1:02 pm. There would be no jury, only a judge. She waited for the knock at the door, the ride in the back of a police cruiser, the good cop/bad cop interrogation. They are so insecure, and pissed and low in their own lives they have to pass judgment on something that happened 30 years ago! The knife caught Kirsten twice in the stomach, then in her hand as Kirsten raised her arm to protect her body. I do not think anything has changed but perhaps more [competition] and stress, Palmer said. Kirstens was a Ranch type home. if ( notice )
Or any teen girl period. Kirsten Marina Costas (July 23, 1968 - June 23, 1984) was an American high school student who was murdered by her classmate Bernadette Protti in June 1984. Though time has passed, the murder is still a disturbing memory for a generation of Moraga residents. People change and grow up, get jobs,families and have Children to raise and even Grandkids, so we dont have the time for the High School Drama anymore. Miramonte was the only high school in the town, and a microcosm of the social world to the kids of Orinda. The knife was huge. Costas was banging her fists on the door as Protti jumped out of the bushes and stabbed her with a butcher knife in a downward angle several times, puncturing her lungs. Her sister had the knife in the car for work and [Protti] knew where it was., In 1985, author Rob Haeseler wrote TheSan Francisco Chronicle article, Trial Hears Girls Confession of East Bay Slaying. It reported that Protti only wanted to hurt Costas. Costas attended Miramonte High School, where she participated in cheerleading and on the varsity swim team. Bernadette was paroled from the California Youth Authority at the ripe old age of 23. Kirstens parents argued that no ones cutting up tomatoes with a knife thats almost half a metre long. The 2014 film Mean Girl Murderer Case, depicts two girls who kill a friend when they fear she knows about their lesbian relationship. The are laws for both. May she rest in peace. Kirsten would surely tell everyone how weird Bernadette was. Bernadette had enough friends, and was Popular enough that she didnt need Kirsten, so it would of been best she left her alone. Dont say that! Palmer remembered telling her daughter. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. literally. If the prosecution accepted this, it would save the county a lot of money that they could then spend on more important things. That is also why her fingerprints didnt show up when she was in nursing school. What a bitter pill to swallow. Kirsten told Bernadette to pull in to the parking lot of a church her family regularly attended. Kirsten was immature and would have told people what had happened, Palmer explained. This is the true story of 15-year old Kirsten Costas who was stabbed to death by a classmate, Bernadette Protti, on June 23, 1984. ' Palmer said. 30 years ago, 15-year-old Costas was lured by a fake invitation for the Bob-O-Links service group dinner. I doubt she was any worse than any other teen girl, I guarantee you she wouldnt of done what Bernadette did. On 1st April 1985, Bernadette was sentenced. Mother Elaine was a homemaker, who read her bible with a stop watch. The FBI man thinks I did it. The speculation on whether of not this had anything to do with homosexuality, is asinine to say the least. I think something had already snapped in Jeannette and she was going to kill Kisten if she didnt agree to be her friend. Bridget Moretti, also known as Bernadette Protti (a murderer of Kirsten Costas), is a well-known character. None of this is normal behavior. . According to Bernadette, they sat in the car for 40 minutes, with Kirsten offering her marijuana. Protti was sentenced to a maximum of nine years, but was released seven years later on parole. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Also this movie is basically saying feel sorry for the girl who did MURDERED another girl ( in my opinion). Nancy had once told Kirsten in front of others that if she didnt shut up Nancy would kill her. var notice = document.getElementById("cptch_time_limit_notice_28");
Costas' parents vehemently opposed Protti's release. Brutal. D.M. Anonymous Jan 2, 2019 at 5:20 pm. Miss Protti had been charged with first-degree murder in the June 23 death of 15-year-old Kirsten Costas near Miss Costas' home. BARC shelter in Brooklyn founder Vinny Spinola,, He was one of the six shelters 25 years ago at the first Broadway Barks even helping setting up the tables,, a great loss we will miss you,, love you so Vinny .
She also . However, those who knew Bernadette would later state that she would absolutely have accepted marijuana if she thought it would increase her social credibility. Why? Bernadettes mother screamed and put her head down when she saw the knife in trial, said Palmer. Its never too late for Jeanette to say, I killed someone and I have to live with that the rest of my life. So they never made the phone call to the Weems to confirm. Anonymous Jan 4, 2020 at 6:45 pm. When Costas could not reach her parents by telephone, Alex Arnold drove her home, noticing that a pinto- Protti family's car-was following them. Bernadette idolised Kirsten because of the apparent ease with which she seemed to traverse the social minefield. The film "is inspired by Randall Sullivans Rolling Stone article of the same name about the real-life murder of a popular, affluent and beautiful Northern California high school cheerleader at the hand of a classmate, as Lifetime described it. But Bernadette did all of this lying to impress Kirsten, the girl whom she simultaneously hated and admired. It's based on the 1984 Bernadette Protti murder case in Orinda, California. Bernadette wasnt poor at all. Your IP: I would worry more about yourselves, and making sure you live a decent life because it does not seem half of you even are righteous in any way!! People thought it was drugs, but I got that feeling from the trial., [Costas] had no way of knowing that Bernadette was thinking a great deal about her, stated another article in 1985 by People magazine. She made a pass at her. Well, if shes now married with several children, she probably isnt gay and never was. https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-197, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-178, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-195, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-176, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-145, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-130, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-129, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-111, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-110, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-107, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-106, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-105, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-98, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-96, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-95, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-93, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-89, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-88, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-87, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-82, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-79, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-78, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-76, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-54, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-53, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-51, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-44, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-23, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-196, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-22, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-19, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-18, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-17, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-16, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-14, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-11, https://thecampoclaw.com/lifestyle/2014/10/14/murder-still-haunts-moraga-resident/#comment-10, Costas, a Miramonte cheerleader, was murdered by fellow student Bernadette Protti in June of 1984. She didnt care about the consequences morally. Orinda Native youre right, I didnt know Kirsten, but had a friend whose friend knew her, said she was Stuck up, but no Bully and didnt deserve to be murdered. viewed 15 April 2017, Clickamericana.com The Real Death of a Cheerleader Story Costas, a Miramonte cheerleader, was murdered by fellow student Bernadette Protti in June of 1984. MARTINEZ, Calif. -- The murder trial of a high school girl accused of fatally stabbing a classmate -- a popular cheerleader -- out of jealousy began Monday, and the first two witness called were. Yet, when the FBI took over the case, they found that Protti, who was thought to have passed her initial lie detector test, was actually lying. One of the students that appeared to epitomise Bernadettes definition of success was a girl in her year level called Kirsten Costas. Another girl, Nancy Kane, had also attended. She started following Kirstens lead, figuring that if she simply travelled the same road, she would achieve the same result. Unfortunately Kirsten instead decided to reject Bernadette and Bernadette snapped. Kirsten said she was out with a friend, but that her friend had gotten weird on her. slated to air February 2 at 8/7c on Lifetime. Picture 61.png /. Once the timer went off, she put the bible down, opened the letter and read: I have been trying to tell you this all day but I love you so much its too hard so Im taking the easy way out. Kirsten would of Outgrown her ways and probaly she and Bernadette would of been Civil to one another today. Bernadette didnt want Kirsten to expose and embarrass her? Your donation will support the student journalists of Campolindo High School's The Claw. I just wish Bernadette would come clean and public about it all. viewed 15 April 2017, Murderpedia.com Bernadette Protti Even drunk DUI they dont mean to kill, but they did, yes, they have to live with it to, but a Senseless Murder is Unacceptable.