"Is Severus Snape really Harry's dad?" It appears that he also played his part very well. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Warner Bros. Pictures. Does this make Dumbledore a bad guy and Snape a hero? What made them think THAT, of all things. ". Would love to hear what anyone else thinks about it. I'm honestly tired of hearing the theory that Snape is Harry's "real dad" because if he was really Snapes son then WHYYYY Was literally never attracted to Snape, and why does Harry have ALMOST ALLLL of James' physical features INCLUDING hair, height, eye wear, and physical body type other than the fact that he was raised on very little food. Not close enough to affect patronus though - or all wizards and witches who aren't muggle born would have the same form. When we came out of the theatre my sister was wide eyed and shocked I felt proud that I read the books and she didnt because she looked confused so I told her in the I-read-the-book-and-you-didnt tone "Al right Alice what is it that got you confused from the movie I can answer ANYTHING.." she turned to me and said: "One question: Is Snape Harry's REAL father" I just wanted to slap her when I heard that question and its not just her my friends asked me THE SAME THING. The real idiots are those who insult someones intelligence because they didn't read the book. Because of this, quite naturally, we identify him as a villain. If by real you mean through genes the answer to that is James Potter. Death Eater. And, in fact, Snape is working against him to protect Harry. They were born in the same month and year. Due to the age difference between Rickman and Snape, as he is portrayed in the book, make-up was used on Rickman to make him look younger. Enotes has an extensive collection of Harry Potter reference material. I can't remember if they included that detail in the film or not, though. 3. About point 2, what Dumbledore meant was that a Patronus changing shape from love and loss isn't something curious, it's normal. The movie watchers are confused, just as I am, because when Harry is in the pensive with Snape's memories, Snape and DD are talking. However, what he doesn't know is that Snape is secretly helping him. What seemed to be a childrens story has now become a dark and nuanced one. Snape was a Slytherin when he was at Hogwarts, and like many students in that house, he excelled at Potions, the Dark Arts, and Charms. Please, I think you're on to something. She also cleared up doubt as to whether Professor Snape held malice against Harry or his father, James Potter. Since his happiest and most loving memories were with Harry's mother, Lily, his Patronus took the same form as hers which is what made Harry follow it in the first place. While Harry is facing Voldemort, he calls Snape "Professor Snape". He appears to do something wrong and yet, in the end, it turns out that he was acting in Harrys best interests. As Harry begins his third year at Hogwarts, he receives an alarming piece of information. All Rights Reserved. Fortunately, Rowling always seems eager to fill in the blanks for her readers. He'd have been mean to Harry deliberately to prevent anyone from guessing the truth from favouritism then, I guess. Snape was not Harrys father. This is eventually revealed to be a by-product of Snape's lingering resentment for Harry's father, James -- who had been a major rival to Snape in their youth. Alan Rickman, the actor who brought the character to life, was the only one . 2023 TIME USA, LLC. Harry names his son after both Hogwarts directors: Albus Severus. And, in the same way, we understand that good old Dumbledore wasnt quite as good as we thought he was. Rowling has shared a number of revelations since the Harry Potter books and films wrapped upincluding the fact that Dumbledore was gay. If you like the idea of Snape secretly being Harrys dad, there are fanfics devoted to this trope that you can read, just know theyre not canon. He savesthe boy's life on multiple occasions, which Dumbledore notes to Harry is partly because James had once saved Snape's life when he was a member of the Marauders. Exploring your mind Blog about psychology and philosophy. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. The Harry Potter books and movies are filled with unforgettable characters, from students like Hermione Granger and bullies like Draco Malfoy to professors like Minerva McGonagall and the villainous Lord Voldemort. 29. Upon their shared arrival at Hogwarts, Lily is furious at Snape for sabotaging her relationship with her sister, and matters only get worse from there. BOOM, People obviously don't pay enough attention and they are lost in the moment of the realisation of snape actually being a pretty good guy, because at first I felt the same way too, People think Snape is Harry Potter's father even though James Potter is Harry's because Dumbledore said "Make sure Harry is safe and pretend that you're is his father.". According to the official Wizarding World site, his last name is based on the Old Norse word "sneypa" meaning "to outrage, disgrace or dishonor." Snape's death is one of the most emotional moments in the series. "It is my Hogwarts letter." Harry passed the letter to his mother and was smiling from ear to ear. In the books, the resemblance between James and Harry is pretty much stuffed down our throats, but it isn't possible to find two unrelated actors who'd be that similar. I mean really!! It's just a fact. Because the movies leave out more than half the details from the books. While Snape and Lily try to remain close despite their differences, Lily disapproves of Snape's friends all of whom later become Death Eaters under Voldemort while Snape can't stand James Potter, one of Gryffindor's most popular students, who's clearly carrying a torch for Lily. ". Following that incident, Severus Snape passed the counterfeit sword to Bellatrix Lestrange. @ClaireVoyant: OMFH ROFLMMFAO Right on. Thoughts? Meanwhile, other characters, like Harry, try to unmask him. J.K. Rowling spells it out, clear as day, in "The Chamber of Secrets." Snape already knew about the world of magic, and was, in some ways, a key figure in Lilys childhood. Because, in the end, we all make mistakes, we can all act wrongly in certain situations. The truth is never as simple as this; the world isnt only made up of good people and bad people there are nuances in between. This is the first time that he addresses him with the title other than in his presence which shows that he has forgiven and even come to respect Snape for his courage and his sacrifices. This unrequited love led him to resent James Potter, Harrys father, and eventually Harry, too. But if they don't quit asking, tell them to tell you the reason why they think Snape is Harry's father. The Harry Potter saga grows in perfect harmony with its main character. There is no reason to question that James may not be Harrys dad. It's probably a conspiracy theory or something like that. Tonks' patronus is another example of tragic/unrequited love changing a patronus. Harry Potter Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Because in the movie, dh2, in the death scene where harry is talking to dumbledore in the train station, harry references the visions he had from snapes tears. How much he loved her. Snape stays by Voldemort's side throughout the Battle of Hogwarts, which turns out to be a fatal mistake. He was only 21 days older than her. Dolores Umbridge also casts a Patronus (in the form of a cat) during "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.". Sirius Black, a wanted murderer accused of killing 13 wizards with a single curse, has escaped Azkaban the wizarding prison and is apparently hunting Harry. *sigh* new in fandom, just wait a few months. Dumbledore just said that this patronus mirroring wasn't that weird. Did Snape steal sword? As readers or viewers, were surprised that no one besides Harry and his friends is aware of Snapes evil. Movies might not follow to the letter, but they can't really change something as drastic as the main character's parentage. For example, Harry spends literally the entirety of book 6 relating to and identifying with the Half-Blood Prince. Next Ron and Hermione, sittin' in a tree. This relationship will be key to discovering more about Snape as an adult in the Harry Potter saga. Snape didn't know that he was the father of Harry, hell, even Harry didn't know. Severus Snape is one of the most intriguing characters in the Harry Potter saga. One fan asked about what Snape smells like, and although the original tweet with the question has since been deleted, Rowling's reply is still up. But based on the description of the position on Wizarding World, it seems like Snape was destined for the role. In 2015, the series' author began answering a slew of fan questions on Twitter. What a funny, but undeniable explanation. When we read The Philosophers Stone, we find a book for children, where evil and goodness seem to be the two extremes. Well for one, some make fanfictions and theories about the story. When Harry explores them, he learns everything he needs to know. Snape is pedantic, arrogant, and lacks empathy. In Snape's memories, there was a lot to do with Lily in there. The site reads, "The popular idea of a Potions expert within the wizarding community is of a brooding, slow-burning personality.". Snape headed up the stairs and to room 234 and knocked. There's a whole essay in why Harry gave his son Snape's name, but the decision goes to the heart of who Harry was, post-war. Is there something in the movie DH-part 2 made them think Snape is Harry's father ?? In this 'Snape is the father of Harry story' nobody knows that Snape is the father of Harry. Published Aug 27, 2022. Rather than attending Hogwarts for his seventh and final year, Harry continues the work he started with Dumbledore and hunts down Voldemort's horcruxes, objects containing pieces of the Dark Lord's soul. Snape rushed to the Shack, unaware he was walking into a lethal situation. DD says.don't tell me you've come to care for the boy. The D answers by saying its not curious at all. Alan Rickman played Snape in the "Harry Potter" films. Is Snape a repentant mortal? Although we know he wasn't always this way, Snape seemed to have grown into the position quite comfortably by Harry's first year. However, she had a huge secret prepared that change everything. Seeing as he was a double agent, this also fits. There was adventure, heartbreak, and even deathall the elements that . Hate him. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry Potter Page to Screen: The Complete Filmmaking Journey, LEGO Harry Potter: Building the Magical World, LEGO Harry Potter: Characters of the Magical World, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore, Magic Beyond Words: The J.K. Rowling Story, Fantastic Beasts: Cases from the Wizarding World, Creator: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Attack on Godric's Hollow (1981) participants, Battle of the Astronomy Tower participants, Defence Against the Dark Arts Professors at Hogwarts, Plot to assassinate Albus Dumbledore participants, Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures, Murder of Severus Snape in Shrieking Shack, http://www.accio-quote.org/articles/2007/0726-today-vieira1.html. Well what is it?" Lily asked. In the Deathly Hallows Part 2, it seemed like Snape could have possibly been Harry's father from: James' Animagus form was a stag, hence the nickname of Prongs. I know for a second I was thinking the same thing but in all the movies & books they say he's a spitting image of James but has his mothers eyes. Search engines. For this reason, its a much bigger surprise when we discover the truth. "Well Harry Minnie said that you received a post today. I'm just really confused that they think that way. after the character's death. What J.K Rowling Doesn't Want You To Know About Harry Potter's ParentsSubscribe: http://bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Things DO YOU BELIEVE IN MAGIC | Potterheads: h. As far as readers and viewers know, Snape was the only Death Eater to cast a Patronus spell throughout the series. I also find it insulting to lily because it implies she's a cheater. Severus Snape's biggest regret. This thread is archived Continue Reading 347 Sponsored by Elated Stories Also, Snape's love for Lily was most definitely romantic by the end. But maybe when Voldemort kills Snape, and he gives the teardrop to Harry, maybe that confused her or something. This was likely due to the film's PG-13 rating. It's especially bad since James has a penchant for bullying Snape. :) <3, I found it annoying as well but Harry said to Albus, Snapes patronus is a doe, isn't that courious & Albus said no. What are the main settings of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? Patronus doesn't indicate bloodline. Harrys plans almost always fail, and Snape comes out on top every time. Though Snape begs for her forgiveness, particularly because Lily was defending him against James, he can't justify hurting Lily, and she gives up on him for good. Harry Potter was neglected, that much is certain among the Harry Potter community. Born to Muggle Tobias Snape and witch Ellen Prince, young Severus Snape has a difficult childhood due to a strained and often angry relationship between his parents, which Harry personally witnesses when he accidentally glimpses one of Snape's private childhood memories. 2006-2023 Fanpop, Inc., All Rights Reserved. During Harry's sixth year, the Boy Who Lived finds himself completely consumed by a few mysteries. That's because Snape has always liked Lily since childhood. I guess alot of those who read the book know nothing about movies and how thay make things appear to be something their not and oh yeah EVERY DETAIL is not included in a movie from a book and important details get left out. The deaths at the Battle of Hogwarts would haunt Harry forever. How does fear control us, and why might it be hard to be Latest answer posted August 22, 2019 at 4:46:51 PM. lol. Is there such a thing as pure goodness? Snape begs Dumbledore never to tell anybody that he's protecting Harry, and the heartbroken wizard agrees to the painful task. Severus is also forced to wear mismatched clothes, suggesting he may have been neglected by his parents. Actually he did meet Lily again after he called her mudblood. It's been many years since the first Harry Potter movie Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone made its way to theaters. Magazines, Digital It must have said Severus Snape. He ultimately turned down the "Harry Potter" role, paving the way for Rickman's iconic portrayal. They dusted it in the film. I guess I just read it wrong. well,snape is like harry's stepfather because he loved lily but lily saw james so lily liked him and when the sorting hat was putting everyone into houses james and lily did the dramatic stare so they loved each other so they got married, Being in love with someone's mother doesn't make that someone your stepchild.