As he tells it, while the other SEALs were clearing nearby rooms and exchanging fire with bin Ladens bodyguards, he and a point man moved through the compound to the third floor. IBT Fast Start - Let the best of International News come to you. O autor Mark Owen durante entrevista a CBS Reproduo/VEJA. To have [ONeill] be a part of it and to hear his account is a unique opportunity for the people who are going to attend the [lecture] event.. Bissonnette, who used the pseudonym Mark Owen, claimed that he had delivered the fatal shot to bin Laden after the point man had wounded him. matt bissonnette vs robert o'neillis jim acosta married. I am amazed that there hasn't been at least 30 generals and admirals that haven't resigned or been fired today. AIR Awareness Outreach; AIR Business Lunch & Learn; AIR Community of Kindness; AIR Dogs: Paws For Minds AIR Hero AIR & NJAMHAA Conference See the complete profile on LinkedIn and discover matt's . 12 September 2017. In his death throes, he was still twitching and convulsing, he wrote about Bin Laden. In the end, the department did not bring any criminal charges, settling instead for the cash forfeitures. " Rob " O'Neill (born April 10, 1976) is a former United States Navy sailor. Mr. Bissonnette said in a statement Friday that he regretted his failure to submit No Easy Day for vetting before it was published in 2012 so Pentagon officials could ensure that it did not include classified information. Neil Roberts was the first member of SEAL Team 6 to die in the Afghan war, and among the first elite operators who died after 9/11. Mr. Bissonnette acknowledged that he was required under his security clearances to let the Pentagon review the book, and he blamed another lawyer for advising him that he did not need to do so. However, in his Oct. 12 interview, Parrot also indicated that Biden orchestrated the deaths of Seal Team Six in order to ensure their silence about the Abbottabad raid. (But probably dating back to Prussian Field Marshal Helmuth Von Moltke, whose rather less pithy remark was, No operation extends with any certainty beyond the first encounter with the main body of the enemy.). The presidential library obtained the gear after one of its employees met ONeill at an event earlier this year, said Nixon Foundation communications director Joe Lopez. I got into the famous bin Laden bedroom because they led me there. But other military officials and SEALs took issue with Mr. ONeills account. While Mr. Bissonnettes fight with the Pentagon over his book has received public attention, some details of his consulting work while he was still a SEAL Team 6 member, as well as his fee forfeiture, have not been disclosed. ONeill is not solely responsible for killing bin Laden; rather, he is someone who fortuitously found himself at the end of a very long kill chain. Doesn't know if it's Khalid or not. Printre membrii acelei uniti s-a numrat Matt Bissonnette, care mpreun cu un alt membru al echipei Seal 6, O'Neill, susine c a tras focurile de arm fatale. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. His lecture at the Nixon Library will also include a book signing. Trump believe that Obama administration officials arranged for Osama Bin Laden's transfer to Pakistan, in order to allow for a later "trophy kill" orchestrated by the Obama administration? She [the employee] asked him if he wanted to speak at the library, Lopez said. In 2010, he was the subject of an Icelandic documentary film in which he recounted his life and career as a professional falconer, leaving the United States at the age of 18 and traveling to the Middle East to train, raise, and sell falcons to wealthy sheikhs, businessmen, and politicians. Instead, a Navy recruiter suggested that O'Neill enlist in the U.S. Navy, telling him that he could be a sniper in the U.S. Navy SEALs. Noe also claims that the Obama administration's purported payments to Iran were related to the bin Laden raid and speculates that the man killed in the Abbottabad raid may have, in fact, been bin Laden's "double.". The revelation comes years after LALATE uncovered details about former SEAL Team Six member Matt Bissonnette who is set to release now a second book under the name Mark Owen. Former Navy SEAL Matt Bissonnette is sorry for publishing a tell-all book about the raid that killed al Qaeda leader Osama bin Ladenwithout first seeking a government security review. Its unknown if the point man hit bin Laden, and if those shots killed him. Bin Laden stood to ONeills right, near the door of an adjoining room, with his hands on a womans shoulders and a calm expression on hisface. U.S. forces also killed three other adult males in what was described as a firefight. The display of ONeills uniform in the lobby of the Nixon Library is free for visitors to view. A former commander of SEAL Team 6 said in an interview that he believed Mr. ONeill fired insurance rounds into Bin Ladens body, after he was down. But as is often said at the Pentagon, No plan survives contact with the enemy a quote variously attributed to Napoleon, Dwight Eisenhower, or George Patton. For instance, ONeills narrative has been dubbed FUBAR by other members of SEAL Team Six. Its a historic mission. In a letter last week, the admiral and senior enlisted man who run the United States Naval Special Warfare Command reminded all present and former SEALs that a critical tenet of the organizations ethos is: I do not advertise the nature of my work, nor seek recognition for my actions., Violators of our Ethos are neither teammates in good standing, nor Teammates who represent Naval Special Warfare, Rear Adm. Brian Losey and Force Master Chief Michael Magaraci wrote. We don't. My reading of what has been said about O'Neil's participation in the incident is that he shot into bin Laden's corpse after he was dead. Snopes. 19 August 2016. The Christian Science Monitor has expired. The display also presents a copy of ONeills newly released book, The Operator, which he will discuss at a lecture in the Nixon Librarys East Room from 7 to 8 p.m. July 26. I don't care if they hate me. Mr. Bissonnette has maintained that he cleared the consulting work in advance with a Navy lawyer, and Mr. Luskin said that helped persuade prosecutors that there was clearly on Matts part no intent to breach the conflict-of-interest laws. Navy officials say they have restricted such moonlighting since then. We will actively seek judicial consequence for members who willfully violate the law, and place our Teammates, our Families, and potential future operations at risk, the letter said. Bin Laden's body was positively identified and he was buried at sea. O'Neill is not the only one who has come under fire. In 1992, while living in Santa Fe, New Mexico, Khalsa legally changed his name back to Alan Howell Parrot. 1995 - 2023 by Snopes Media Group Inc. Mr. Luskin also noted that a number of high-level officials have assisted other authors writing about the Bin Laden raid as well as the creators of the movie Zero Dark Thirty. But, he said, only Mr. Bissonnette has paid any penalties for the disclosures. I don't want to touch that.". In the short clip promoted by Trump, Noe repeats Parrot's claim that three CIA directors were responsible for arranging Osama bin Laden's peaceful house arrest in Iran for several years. He has been embedded as part of the special services six times over the past five years and has covered deployment in both Iraq and . Shortly afterward, Twitter permanently banned @The171111 for what a company spokesperson told Snopes was a violation of its "ban evasion" policy. 19 August 2020. peterson bulk tobacco. From there, they used various methods to gather information on the layout of the compound and to ascertain bin Laden's presence within it. an unauthorized best-selling book about the raid called No Easy Day,, the Pentagon successfully sued Bissonnette, By many accounts, that helicopter should have crashed disastrously. Snopes. Robert J. O'Neill (born 10 April 1976) is a former United States Navy SEAL (1996-2012), TV news contributor, and author. Office of the Press Secretary. Matt Bissonnette wrote the best-seller "No Easy Day" under the pseudonym "Mark . 12 November 1980. Robert O'Neill, the retired Navy SEAL who says he shot al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden in the forehead publicly identified himself Thursday amid a debate among special operations brethren. [The point man] literally whispers, not amped up, not yelling, not anything. Its not your life, he continues. If anything, he says, its the exact opposite. Before joining Times Community News, she spent two years writing for the Orange County Registers Varsity Arts section. In brief, the U.S. intelligence community identified a courier known to bin Laden, which then led them to a suspicious compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan. The following is a summary of some of the major factual and logical problems with the conspiracy theory promoted repeatedly by Trump in October 2020, a theory he later said he "put out there" for public consumption: Two individuals widely understood to have taken part in the killing of bin Laden Robert O'Neill and Matt Bissonnette have spoken publicly about their respective roles in the Abbottabad raid. "And that's how you should feel. President Joe Biden said on Friday that the U.S. government will evacuate Americans remaining in Afghanistan as well as U.S. Afghan allies who may now be in danger from the Taliban. O'Neill's page on the website of the organization describes his career as a SEAL, but makes no mention of a role in killing bin Laden. The second story of heroism surrounds the point man on the raid: The unnamed SEAL who led the stack up the stairs, a stack of SEALs that likely included ONeill and Bissonnette. Robert O'Neill's new memoir gives readers a front-row seat to the terrorist's execution. He even says he could feel the tension when he and the rest of SEAL Team Six flew to Fort Campbell a few days later to meet President Barack Obama. He had been due to give a. But in recent years former SEALs have been all over the best-seller list, with snipers and dog handlers. logged you out. matt has 3 jobs listed on their profile. Naval Special Warfare Command, and Naval Special Warfare Force Master Michael Magaraci co-signed a letter that contained thinly veiled criticisms of O'Neill and Bissonnette, writing: A critical [tenet] of our ethos is "I do not advertise the nature of my work, nor seek recognition for my actions." Robert ONeill, 38, a former member of the elite SEAL Team 6, said that he was the assaulter whose two shots killed Bin Laden, according to an account in The Washington Post on Thursday. The book was so rife with classified information that the Pentagon successfully sued Bissonnette and seized much of his profits. "Look, I don't want to be in charge, but if I was - oh I want to get the Americans? He was identified only as the Shooter.. When: Lecture featuring ONeill will take place from 7 to 8 p.m. July 26 at the Nixon Library. This gear will end up in a museum someday. The public squabble among supposedly zip-lipped US Navy SEALs over who, exactly, killed 9/11 mastermind and al Qaeda founder Osama bin Laden has taken another turn. And we can prove it.. Were seen as being global, fair, insightful, and perhaps a bit too earnest. On the day he arrived at the recruitment office, the Marine recruiter was not in. I thought maybe wed get a helmet or his boots, but he gave us everything he had.. But Iran didnt get $150 billion in cash, nor did they receive any money at all from U.S. taxpayers they only regained access to assets that had been frozen in several different countries (not just the U.S.), and the $150 billion figure was merely an upper estimate. In interviews with the magazine, Mr. ONeill had said that the point man, who saw Bin Laden first, shot at the Qaeda leader but missed. "Falconers' Group Expels Undercover Birdman." To suggest that the Taliban shot down the helicopter specifically or exclusively based on information made public by Biden requires believing not only that they somehow knew it had Seal Team Six members on board, but also that they knew those members had taken part in the bin Laden raid (even though they came from an entirely different squadron within Seal Team Six), and that the Taliban would not have fired upon any U.S. military helicopter in that area at that time because they were under attack. The firsthand account of the daring raid was one of several high-profile books and movies involving former Navy SEALS that has led to criticism within a community once known for discretion that Mr. Bissonnette and the others were cashing in on their exploits. - Does Pres. Robert O'Neill, 38, a former member of the elite SEAL Team 6, said that he was the assaulter whose two shots killed Bin Laden, according to an account in The Washington Post on Thursday. The DJHJ Media article uncritically presented, and included partial transcripts of, an interview conducted by Alan Howell Parrot, a Maine falconer, with Nick Noe, who describes himself as a U.S. Air Force veteran and is presented by supporters as a "Benghazi whistleblower," and Charles Woods, the father of Tyrone Woods, a former Navy SEAL who later served as a CIA contract protective officer and was killed in September 2012 while protecting the CIA base in Benghazi, Libya. Accessed 16 October 2020. Get the latest in military news, entertainment and gear in your inbox daily. Former Navy SEAL Robert O'Neill said in an interview with The Washington Post that he was the one who fired the final shot to kill Osama bin Laden in 2011. . 6 July 1992. First, he offered his version of events anonymouslyin the February 2013 Esquire profile, The Shooter. But by November 2014, he had revealed his true identity on FoxNews. Were known as being fair even as the world becomes as polarized as at any time since the newspapers founding in 1908. Haaretz.com, the online English edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, gives you breaking news, analyses and opinions about Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World. She earned her degree in literary journalism from UC Irvine. U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. matt bissonnette vs robert o'neill Register now and get started. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. | . - Does Pres. O'Neill said on Friday that he could evacuate Americans from Afghanistan with "nine guys. . In 2014, two officers who run the Naval Special Warfare Command fired off a stern warning letter to all SEAL teammates about seeking fame. Robert O'Neill, a former U.S. Navy SEAL, speaks at the "Best of Blount" Chamber of Commerce awards ceremony at the Clayton Center for the Arts in Maryville, Tennessee, U.S., on Thursday, Nov. 6. He also repeats the claim that, despite Iran's offer to hand over bin Laden to American custody, Hillary Clinton, Joe Biden and others "cooked up [a] plan" to have bin Laden transferred to Pakistan "for a trophy kill" (i.e. Trump believe that John Brennan, Joe Biden, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, or other Obama administration officials, knowingly allowed Osama Bin Laden to be held peacefully, under effective house arrest, in Iran, for several years after the 9/11 attacks? The Justice Department conducted criminal investigations into whether Mr. Bissonnette had disclosed classified information in his book or speeches and whether he had violated conflict-of-interest laws in consulting for companies that had contracts with SEAL Team 6. This material may not be reproduced without permission. Were run by a church, but were not only for church members and were not about converting people. Mr. Bissonnettes identity was leaked to news outlets before the book was published. Robert J. The Santa Fe New Mexican. The full video of that Oct. 12 interview can be viewed here. [I wanted to let the public know that SEALs] are real people with real families and real emotions and semi-normal lives. Personal life [ edit] Beyond fear, beyond anger. Trump promoted the conspiracy theory twice on Oct. 13. Get stories that empower and uplift daily. realistic spurs signings In 2013, Esquire Magazine ran a long-form piece called The Shooter, which shielded his identity. Around the same time, Bergen wrote: According to present and former members of SEAL Team Six, the point man who fired the shot that likely mortally wounded bin Laden will never in a million years speak publicly about his role in theraid., ONeills voice rises a few decibels when I ask him about the varying accounts of who actually killed bin Laden. ", at least 30 generals and admirals that haven't resigned, Everyone Practices Cancel Culture | Opinion, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | Opinion. The claim by O'Neill, who travels the country giving motivational speeches, was countered by a source close to another SEAL team member. Violators of our ethos are neither teammates in good standing, nor teammates who represent Naval Special Warfare.. And Im going to argue that we change lives precisely because we force open that too-small box that most human beings think they live in. Robert James O'Neill (born April 10, 1976) is a former United States Navy sailor. A critical [tenet] of our Ethos is I do not advertise the nature of my work, nor seek recognition for my actions. We do not abide willful or selfish disregard for our core values in return for public notoriety and financial gain., I dont know who wrote the Ethos, and I dont care, ONeill replies when I bring up the letter to him. Mr. Luskin said that the $180,000 came from Ops-Core, a helmet maker now owned by the Gentex Corporation in Carbondale, Pa., and two tactical-gear manufacturers based in Virginia Beach S&S Precision and London Bridge Trading. Somebody fired first, but others shot bin Laden too including, apparently, a number of SEALs who arrived seconds or minutes later, firing into bin Ladens body. By . When they entered the bedroom at the top of the floor, two women screamed at them; the point man tackled them, assuming they wore suicide vests. Obama, National Security Team Watched Bin Laden Raid in Real Time, Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Hes a highly decorated 16-year veteran of the SEAL community with two Silver Stars, four Bronze Stars with valor, a Joint Service Commendation Medal with valor, and two Navy/Marine Corps Commendations with valor. I dont want to touch that.. We had no interest in outing Robert O'Neill, it was only after we learned he intended to come out on Fox news that one of our writers named. The story of Mr. ONeill, who is scheduled to appear in a Fox News documentary next week, was previously featured in Esquire magazine. Unlike former SEAL Team 6 member Matt Bissonnette (No Easy Day), they do not rush to write books or step forward publicly, because that violates the code of the "quiet professional." Someone . - Does Pres. "Two different people telling two different stories for two different reasons," Bissonnette said in an interview with NBC News. We In Bissonnette's account of the story, he states that he played a direct role in Bin Laden's death, claiming he took some of the shots that hit the mark. We'll examine the most significant ones in detail farther down. The theory has even less credibility when one bears in mind that "Seal Team Six" had nearly 2,000 members, as of 2015, and the SEALs killed in August 2011 were, in any case, widely reported to have come from "Gold Squadron," and those involved in the bin Laden raid three months earlier were widely reported to have come from "Red Squadron.". Robert O'Neill has relived the moment he shot Osama Bin Laden in a viral TikTok video: The former Navy Seal was discussing the historic moment on The . U.S. Central Command. O'Neill came out publicly to take credit for the killing of Osama bin Laden, a decision that did not sit well within the Navy Seal ranks. Others arent so sure. Matt Bissonnette, a member of SEAL Team Six, wrote in his 2012 book No Easy Day that this point man was still on active duty and was bin Laden's true killer. An update on major political events, candidates, and parties twice a week. These special forces operators, meant to be silent-but-deadly in their shadowy forays around the world, arent supposed to be popping off publicly about their exploits certainly not boasting for credit or financial gain. One SEAL in particular gave him a stiff salute, which ONeill interpreted as snarky gesture. brady list police massachusetts; private prisons in montana; cisco fmc change management ip address cli; private owner rentals; comcast new construction department phone number; Robert O'Neill, the self-proclaimed man who killed Osama Bin Laden, has been labeled by ISIS as their number one target in a recent online postings. Every one of my competitors is terrified of me. The official U.S. government version of events is by now well known, and summaries can be found here and here. Trump believe that Osama Bin Laden is dead? The Navy SEALs sent to Pakistan were experienced combat veterans and highly trained for the mission, which included a mockup of bin Ladens compound. The claim that Biden was personally responsible for ordering the slayings of Seal Team Six members is without merit. O'Neill kom offentligt ud for at tage ren for drabet p Osama bin Laden, en beslutning, der ikke sad godt inden for Navy Seal-rkken. Featured Image Credit: Twitter/Robert O'Neill. No executives at the three companies were available for comment. Bissonnette's lawyer, Robert Luskin, acknowledged Thursday that Bissonnette for some time had been under criminal investigation by both the Naval Criminal Investigation Service and the Justice Department for possible violations of a U.S. espionage law because he did not seek official clearance before publishing his book. Two years ago, another SEALs member said he was among those who shot Bin Laden. "Executive Summary (Crash of CH-47D Aircraft in Wardak Province, Afghanistan on 6 August 2011.) O'Neill was born April 10, 1976 in Butte, Montana, where he was raised. Even so, Mr. Bissonnette appeared on 60 Minutes on Sunday to promote a new book this time vetted in advance by the Pentagon and Mr. ONeill has stepped into the public eye. Robert ONeill, the former SEAL identified in several news accounts as the shooter who fired the fatal shot to bin Ladens head at close range, now says it doesnt matter who did so during that US raid on bin Ladens compound hideout in Abbottabad, Pakistan, in 2011. A video presentation from Your Grateful Nation that includes interviews with veterans plays on a screen next to the uniform display at the Nixon Library. And that's it,'" he said. - Does Pres. O'Neill gently but firmly rejects this: "I chalk. That's the reason al Qaeda has been decimated, he joked in the piece, because she broke my fucking heart.. O'Neill was arrested for driving under the influence Friday, April 8, 2016. We don't ask the Taliban permission. Matt Bissonnette vs Robert O'Neill. "Press Briefing by Senior Administration Officials on the Killing of Osama bin Laden." So what exactly happened that night, perONeill? Documents filed in Federal District Court in Alexandria on Friday indicated that Mr. Bissonnette must transfer nearly $6.8 million to the government as part of the settlement. We want to bridge divides to reach everyone. Among the members of that unit was Matt Bissonnette, who along with another Seal Team 6 member, O'Neill, claims to have fired the fatal shots. "Whatever he [O'Neill] says, he says. During the 1980s, he began campaigning against the mistreatment and smuggling of falcons. Parrot also claimed that Biden "paid with the blood of Seal Team Six when he had them killed," suggesting that those deaths were ordered as a kind of "blood sacrifice," to accompany the $152 billion payment to Iran. Sometimes, we call things boring simply because they lie outside the box we are currently in.. "Minutes and Years: The Bin Ladin Operation." There was no autopsy, and he was buried at sea following traditional Islamic procedures to prevent any burial site from becoming a place for would-be militants to gather. According to his biography on the website of Leading Authorities, a speakers bureau, Mr. ONeill retired in 2012 after more than 400 combat missions. But the former Seal Team 6 commander, who also declined to be identified because of the classified nature of the work, said Mr. ONeill had not played a singular role on either mission. Trump's Oct. 13 retweets constituted a promotion by the president of the United States, to his 87 million followers, of extraordinary, inflammatory and baseless allegations and conspiracy theories, aimed at his electoral rival, to which very few social media users would have been exposed, if not for his interventions. Though he may have been the man to pull the trigger, bin Laden is not dead because of Robert ONeill. "Everyone veteran, Marine, airman and navy SEAL coastguards everyone I've talked to today, all they tell me is they feel gross," O'Neill went on. "But we have these people who are in charge that are a disgrace. And I was talking to another SEAL Team Six operator with whom I've served for 20 years. Neither Kuhner, nor anyone else, has ever explained how Biden was personally, directly responsible for the deaths of those Seal Team Six members by being one of several individuals to mention the involvement of Navy SEALs in the bin Laden raid, without specifying the involvement of Seal Team Six, or how anything Biden said or did informed the Taliban of the fact that the helicopter in question had 15 Seal Team Six members on board, along with 23 other U.S. military forces and civilians, all of whom were killed. -Payments to Iran were related. Navy SEALs are meant to keep quiet about their deadly missions around the world. He had been accused of violating federal law after penning a tell-all memoir. Trump believe that former Vice President Biden was responsible for arranging the purported deaths of, or attacks upon, members of Seal Team 6, either in order to secure their silence about the "true" nature of the Abbottabad raid, or as a form of payment or "blood sacrifice" to Iran, in order to preserve Iran's silence as to the "true" nature of the Abbottabad raid? Robert J. O'Neill (also Rob O'Neill; born 1975 or 1976) is a motivational speaker, Fox News contributor, and former United States Navy SEAL (1996-2012). MailOnline revealed that O'Neill is 'The . Although Losey and Magaraci did not name O'Neill and Bissonnette in the letter, the context makes it clear that they were their intended targets, and the letter therefore constitutes de facto confirmation of O'Neill and Bissonnette's roles in the bin Laden raid. Apr 29, 2017 . Obama White House. Our work isn't possible without your support. It contained the following text: Benghazi whistleblower Nick Noe Real news, real hope. Anyone could have been in that position, said the former senior member, who declined to be identified given the classified nature of the teams work. She was prominent in pushing Parrot and Noe's conspiracy theories on Twitter in October 2020. Task & Purpose spoke with a member of the SEAL community under the condition of anonymity who said that SEALs and many in the special operations community are pissed that ONeill is now stepping up to claim the spotlight. According to the site, public revelations about the Bin Laden raid had led to a rift in the tight-knit community of America's special operations warriors. The top SEALs in Naval Special Warfare Command, Rear Adm. Brian Losey and Force Master Chief Michael Magaraci even went as far as to write a letter to the entire command about not seeking fame or fortune as a result of their duties. In the corner of the room, Bin Ladens 2-year-old son was wobbling on his two chubby legs, crying. A 2017 report from The Intercept claimed that O'Neill did shoot bin Laden but the Al-Qaeda leader may already have been dead. SEAL Team Six member Matt Bissonnette claimed in his book No Easy Day that O'Neill did not deliver the fatal shot. Does it matter? A native of Butte, Mont., Mr. ONeill told The Montana Standard in 2013 that he was the lead paratrooper on Seal Team 6s mission to rescue a commercial ship captain, Richard Phillips, who had been taken hostage by Somali pirates in 2009, and had earlier helped rescue a fellow SEAL member, Marcus Luttrell, in Afghanistan. NBC News quoted Bissonnette on Thursday as saying: "Two different people telling two different stories for two different reasons Whatever he (O'Neill) says, he says. Blandt medlemmerne af denne enhed var Matt Bissonnette, der sammen med et andet Seal Team 6-medlem, O'Neill, hvder at have affyret de fatale skud. The following is an exact transcript of the questions we asked: - Does Pres. According to the theory, Biden ordered the deaths either to keep the members of "Seal Team Six" from disclosing that the raid was a sham that had killed only bin Laden's "double," or as a form of "blood sacrifice" to Iran, in return for the silence of Iranian officials on the "true" nature of the May 2011 operation in Abbottabad, Pakistan. That sniper had to face a lot ofsnark., And hes steadfast that he didnt write The Operator to glory-hog or cash in on his military service and involvement in the bin Laden mission. I don't think we know who killed bin L.